Annuities — Compare Rates, Carriers & Reviews (2026) | Track Retirement

We show your options. You keep more income.

Compare fixed-indexed, MYGA, immediate, and deferred annuities from 20 A.M. Best‑rated carriers — independently scored, no pay-for-ranking.

Fixed-Indexed (FIA)

Market upside, protection from index losses

Fixed-indexed annuities credit a share of an index’s gains. Once credited, interest is protected from later index declines — but withdrawals, fees, and surrender charges can still reduce contract value, and crediting periods vary by contract.

A person planning their retirement income
UPSIDE
Index cap rate10.00%EquiTrust Life · B++
Downside floor0%A market drop alone doesn’t cut your value
Credited interestProtectedProtected from later index declines once credited

Illustrative examples, not quotes or offers. Your actual income or rate depends on your age, the carrier, and the product.

Why retirees trust Track Retirement

  1. 1
    Independent

    No carrier can pay for a better ranking — ever. Every pick is the output of a written scoring rubric, not a commission.

  2. 2
    Strength shown up front

    Every carrier we list shows its current A.M. Best financial-strength rating, and we flag any carrier rated below A‑ or placed under review. Annuity guarantees are backed solely by the issuing insurer’s claims-paying ability — they are not FDIC-insured and not bank guaranteed.

  3. 3
    Built from primary sources

    Our guides and rankings are built from primary sources — A.M. Best, NAIC, the IRS, and SSA — and updated as rates and rules change.

*Illustrative, not a quote or offer: a $1,000,000 single-premium immediate annuity, male aged 70, life-only (the highest-paying option; payments stop at death), from our representative payout table checked October 2026. Before taxes; backed by the issuing insurer’s claims-paying ability. Actual income varies by age, sex, carrier, state and payout choice.

Every rate and rule traced to primary sources

Illustrative MYGA rate examples

Highest effective annual yield by term among the A- and better carriers we list, last checked October 13, 2026 · illustrative, not a quote. See the full rate table →

2-year · effective yield 4.80%Synergy Choice MYGA · Oct 13, 2026 Aspida Life · A.M. Best A-
3-year · effective yield 5.70%Synergy Choice MYGA · Oct 13, 2026 Aspida Life · A.M. Best A-
5-year · effective yield 6.30%Synergy Choice MYGA · Oct 13, 2026 Aspida Life · A.M. Best A-
7-year · effective yield 6.35%Synergy Choice MYGA · Oct 13, 2026 Aspida Life · A.M. Best A-
10-year · effective yield 6.00%MyGuarantee Plus · Oct 12, 2026 Lincoln Financial · A.M. Best A

Published rates for one named product per carrier (last checked October 13, 2026) — not quotes or offers; effective yield before taxes. The top rate at a term can come from a lower-rated carrier — check the A.M. Best grade.

20 A.M. Best-rated carriers, independently scored
Athene A+Aspida Life A-Atlantic Coast Life C+Sentinel Security Life C+Oceanview Life AEquiTrust Life B++Americo Financial Life ANationwide A+Pacific Life A+New York Life A++MassMutual A++Lincoln Financial AGlobal Atlantic AF&G Annuities ASymetra AAllianz Life A+Brighthouse Financial ANorth American Co. A+Western & Southern A+Mutual of Omaha A+

Best annuity companies of 2026

Top carriers scored on rate competitiveness, financial strength, product breadth, and customer experience.

  1. 1
    Athene A+ Strong MYGA rates across terms

    4.8/5 — One of the largest U.S. fixed annuity carriers and a consistent leader on MYGA rates.

    Read review
  2. 2
    New York Life A++ Highest-rated annuity carrier

    4.8/5 — A++ rated mutual carrier with a conservative, long-established balance sheet.

    Read review
  3. 3
    Nationwide A+ Best big-name carrier for MYGA

    4.7/5 — Major mutual carrier with broad annuity lineup and strong financial ratings.

    Read review
  4. 4
    Pacific Life A+ Top-tier carrier for income annuities

    4.7/5 — Premium mutual carrier known for income annuities and strong financial standing.

    Read review
  5. 5
    MassMutual A++ Top-rated mutual carrier

    4.7/5 — A++ rated mutual carrier with deep retirement-income expertise.

    Read review

Annuity guides

Plain-English explainers, updated for 2026 rates and rules.

Guide MYGA vs. CD: which pays more in 2026?

MYGAs often out-yield same-term CDs and defer the tax, but the gap moves with rates — here is how to compare a specific MYGA's effective yield against a CD's APY. Here's exactly when that gap is worth the trade-offs.

Guide What is a fixed annuity? A plain-English guide

Fixed annuities pay an insurer-guaranteed rate for a set term and defer tax until you withdraw — not FDIC-insured, with surrender charges for early exits. Here's how they work in 2026.

Guide Pros and cons of annuities in 2026

Annuities solve real retirement income problems — but the wrong product can lock you in for decades. Here's the honest tradeoff list.

Guide Annuity vs. 401(k): how they actually compare

These two retirement products aren't substitutes — they solve different problems. Here's when each is the better choice.

Guide How to buy an annuity: a step-by-step buyer's guide

From defining the goal to comparing carriers to signing the contract — exactly what to do (and not do) when buying an annuity.

Guide Annuities vs. bonds: which is right for retirement?

Both provide fixed income, but they're not interchangeable. Here's how MYGAs and SPIAs compare to bonds and bond funds.

Guide Fixed vs. fixed-indexed annuities: what's the difference?

Fixed annuities guarantee a rate; indexed annuities credit 0% instead of a market loss but cap your gains. Both guarantees depend on the issuing insurer. Here's how to choose.

Guide What is a SPIA (Single Premium Immediate Annuity)?

A SPIA converts a lump sum into guaranteed lifetime income, starting within 12 months. Here's how they work and when to use one.

Annuity FAQs

What is an annuity?

An annuity is a contract with an insurance company: you give them a lump sum (or a series of payments) and they guarantee something in return — a fixed interest rate for a set period (MYGA), guaranteed income for life (SPIA), or market-linked growth with downside protection (FIA).

Which type of annuity should I buy?

It depends on the goal. For a CD alternative with higher tax-deferred yield, choose a MYGA. For guaranteed lifetime income now, choose a SPIA. For market upside with downside protection, choose a FIA.

Are annuities safe?

It depends what you mean by safe. Fixed annuities and SPIAs are not bank products, are not FDIC-insured, and are not guaranteed by any bank or government agency — unlike a CD or a Treasury. Every guarantee depends entirely on the claims-paying ability of the insurance company that issues the contract, which is why the A.M. Best financial-strength rating matters and why we show it beside every carrier. Variable annuities carry market risk in their sub-accounts and can lose value.

How much do annuities cost?

Fixed annuities and MYGAs usually carry no separate annual fee, but that is not the same as free. Withdrawing more than the contract’s free-withdrawal allowance before the term ends triggers a surrender charge and, on many contracts, a market value adjustment, which can cost a meaningful percentage of your principal; the schedule is in the contract, so read it before you sign. Taxable withdrawals before age 59½ may also incur an additional 10% federal tax penalty, and a few states levy a premium tax. Some products credit interest on a simple-interest or first-year-bonus basis, so the effective annual yield is lower than the headline rate. Fixed-indexed annuities may carry rider fees of roughly 0.5%–1.5%, and their caps, participation rates, and spreads limit how much index gain is credited. Variable annuities carry total annual costs of roughly 2%–3.5%. Ask for the surrender schedule and the guaranteed effective annual yield in writing, and confirm every figure against the issued contract.

Where can I get a free annuity quote?

Use the “Get matched” button and we’ll pass your request to an independent, state-licensed insurance agent who can compare carriers for your situation — free and no obligation. Track Retirement is not an insurance agency or licensed agent and does not issue quotes; the agent is paid a commission by the issuing insurer if you buy, and we are paid a referral fee by the agent or agency that receives your request.

How Track Retirement ranks annuity carriers

We score every carrier on rate competitiveness, A.M. Best financial strength, product breadth, surrender flexibility, and state availability. See our full methodology and advertiser disclosure.